Mastering the Setaria Deception: All Correct Dialogue Choices in Genshin Impact

Even years after its release, Genshin Impact continues to captivate players with intricate quests that test more than just combat prowess. The 3.1 Archon quest introduced a particularly tricky segment where the Traveler must help Nahida trick a Grand Sage's assistant named Setaria. Fast forward to 2026, and many adventurers still find themselves stumbling at this memory-based challenge. The mission requires recalling seemingly trivial details from earlier conversations and feeding them back perfectly. How can anyone keep track of cats' names, a dead father's peculiar habits, and rumors in a bustling tavern? The answer lies in knowing exactly which fragments of information matter before the critical moment arrives.

To set the stage, Nahida devises a plan to make Setaria believe the Scarlet King is returning, forcing her to betray the Akademiya's inner circle. Since Nahida cannot directly confront the scholar, she possesses several acquaintances Setaria will visit—a fortune teller, a stonemason, and a tavern patron. The Traveler acts as the mouthpiece, answering Setaria's questions in a way that matches the possessed person's personality and knowledge. One wrong reply and the entire scheme collapses. This high-stakes game of impersonation hinges on three separate encounters, each with its own set of correct responses.

The Fortune Teller: Nabiya

Setaria first seeks out Nabiya, a woman known for her uncanny predictions and a soft spot for her feline companions. At this stage, Nahida speaks through the fortune teller's body, and the Traveler must select lines that sound authentic. The first test comes when Setaria casually asks about the names of Nabiya's cats. After digesting an earlier, seemingly throwaway conversation, the player must remember that the pets are called Harut and Marut. Missing this detail dooms the interaction immediately.

Once the cat name hurdle is cleared, Setaria becomes more receptive and requests a fortune. This is where Nabiya would typically deliver a cryptic but oddly specific prophecy. The correct response here is "You will encounter a person who will change your destiny." It strikes a balance between vague mysticism and personalized insight—exactly what the real Nabiya would say. Does it feel like genuine divination? Perhaps, but Setaria's belief in such arts makes her susceptible. Get either answer wrong, and the whole quest grinds to a halt, forcing a restart from the last checkpoint.

The Stonemason: Akim

With Nabiya's words planting seeds of doubt, Setaria moves on to the stonemason Akim. Nahida now inhabits the rugged artisan, and the Traveler faces two more dialogue checks. When Setaria inquires about Akim's profession, the obvious temptation is to describe a generic trade. However, Akim is not just any craftsman—he is a masonry worker who has spent a lifetime shaping stone. The exact phrase to pick is "Uh, masonry work." The slight hesitation in the delivery is intentional, mirroring Akim's straightforward, unpolished manner.

The second question is far more personal: Setaria asks about Akim's father. Only someone truly close to the family would know the answer, and this is where foreknowledge from earlier eavesdropping pays off. The correct reply is "He always said that a man should be as strong as the stones he shapes." This perfectly encapsulates the father's philosophy and confirms to Setaria that she is indeed speaking with Akim. What would happen if the Traveler chose a different, more generic paternal recollection? Setaria would immediately become suspicious, recognizing the impersonation. The tension here is palpable—one misstep and the entire deceptions unravels.

The Tavern Patron: Qisha

Having been softened by two convincing encounters, Setaria finally arrives at the tavern to speak with Qisha. This is the final hurdle, and the question revolves around city gossip. Setaria wants to know about someone preaching unusual ideas within Sumeru City. After observing Qisha's earlier chatter, the player learns that a man named Jibrail has been spreading controversial teachings. Therefore, when the prompt appears, the only safe choice is "Jibrail." Nothing else will suffice.

With that single name, Setaria's resistance crumbles. She accepts the fabricated reality of the Scarlet King's resurgence and agrees to aid the Traveler and Nahida. From this point forward, any dialogue option becomes inconsequential to the quest's progression—victory is secured. It's remarkable how a few carefully chosen words can turn a loyal Akademiya assistant into an unwitting ally.

Why This Quest Still Matters in 2026

Genshin Impact's world has expanded dramatically since the Sumeru arc, but the Tricking Setaria quest remains a classic example of how the game rewards attentive players. Even with countless guides available, the sheer volume of NPC dialogue can overwhelm newcomers. Can you really blame someone for forgetting Harut and Marut amidst the flood of lore? The quest design intentionally mimics real-life memory lapses, making successful completion all the more satisfying.

For those replaying the Archon questline on alt accounts or returning after a long hiatus, these answers serve as a reliable compass. The three encounters, summarized below, form a tight sequence that tests recollection under pressure. No combat, no elemental reactions—just pure conversational gambits. It's a refreshing change of pace that underscores Nahida's wisdom and the Traveler's adaptability.

Quick Reference Table

For an at-a-glance reminder, here are all the correct responses needed to trick Setaria:

NPC	Question Topic	Correct Response
Nabiya	Cat names	Harut and Marut
Nabiya	Fortune telling	"You will encounter a person who will change your destiny."
Akim	Type of work	"Uh, masonry work."
Akim	Father's saying	"He always said that a man should be as strong as the stones he shapes."
Qisha	Person preaching in the city	Jibrail

With these answers in hand, the once-intimidating task of tricking Setaria becomes a straightforward walk through Sumeru City's vibrant streets. Whether you're a veteran revisiting the story or a fresh-faced traveler encountering this quest for the first time in 2026, memorizing these lines will ensure Nahida's plan unfolds without a hitch. The Akademiya's secrets are poised to be unveiled, all because a few well-chosen words planted a grand lie. Isn't that the essence of a truly memorable RPG moment?